google reviews reviews

What Happens if I Reject a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

Are you negotiating a personal injury settlement offer? Understanding the factors influencing these offers and the potential outcomes of accepting or rejecting them is crucial.

This article explores critical factors impacting settlement offers, the pros and cons of rejecting an offer, and appropriate times.

It also discusses the steps before rejecting an offer and what to expect if you proceed with litigation. Stay tuned to learn more about effectively navigating the personal injury settlement process.

What Is a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

A personal injury settlement offer is a proposal from an insurance company to a claimant intended to compensate for damages, medical expenses, and other financial losses resulting from an accident or injury.

The value of the settlement is calculated based on the severity of the injuries, required medical treatment, and the impact on the claimant’s daily life and future earning potential.

Claimants must provide detailed documentation of their injuries and expenses and may need to negotiate with the insurance company to achieve a fair settlement.

Typical settlement offers include immediate medical costs, long-term care expenses, lost wages, property damage, and emotional distress, aiming to cover the full scope of the claimant’s losses.

What Factors Affect a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

Several factors affect a personal injury settlement offer, including the severity of injuries, total medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

The severity of injuries, ranging from minor to catastrophic, significantly influences the compensation amount, with severe injuries requiring extensive treatment and long-term care.

Medical expenses, both immediate and future, are critical, necessitating detailed documentation of all related costs and expert opinions on ongoing needs.

Lost wages, calculated from past and potential future earnings, require proof of income and employment records.

Pain and suffering, encompassing physical and emotional distress, are evaluated using medical records and personal testimonies to determine fair compensation.

What Happens if I Reject a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

Negotiations Continue: When a settlement offer is rejected, negotiations between the claimant, their insurance claims attorney, and the insurance company often continue to reach a fair agreement.

During this phase, attorneys advocate for their client’s best interests by highlighting solid legal arguments, counteracting unfavorable aspects, and accurately assessing the claim’s value.

Presenting compelling additional evidence, such as medical records, witness testimonies, and expert opinions, is crucial to strengthen the claimant’s position.

Litigation Process Begins: If negotiations fail to produce a satisfactory settlement, the claimant may initiate the litigation process by filing a lawsuit to seek compensation through the courts.

The defendant receives a summons, marking the beginning of formal litigation. Both parties then discover and exchange relevant information and evidence, gather documents, conduct depositions, and prepare for trial.

Expert witnesses may provide specialized insight, and pre-trial motions allow for legal arguments before the trial proceeds.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Rejecting a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?


Opportunity for Higher Settlement: Rejecting an initial settlement offer opens the possibility of negotiating for a higher amount that accurately reflects the claimant’s damages and compensation needs.

For example, a claimant can refuse an offer that doesn’t cover their medical expenses and lost wages, presenting evidence to negotiate or litigate for a more favorable settlement.

Control Over the Outcome: Rejecting a settlement offer allows the claimant to maintain greater control over the negotiation process and outcome.

This control enables the claimant to steer discussions towards more favorable terms, participate actively in strategic negotiations, and pursue tailored settlements that address their unique needs, leading to a more satisfactory and successful resolution.


Time and Expense of Litigation: Engaging in litigation is time-consuming and expensive, often requiring several months to years to resolve. The prolonged process involves mounting attorney fees, court filing fees, expert witness fees, and other related costs, leading to substantial financial burdens.

Additionally, the emotional toll of ongoing litigation, associated with stress and uncertainty, can significantly impact the claimant’s well-being.

Risk of Losing the Case: Entering litigation carries the risk of receiving no compensation if the case is lost. The uncertainty of a courtroom verdict can be daunting, and substantial evidence is crucial to sway the court in one’s favor.

Competent legal representation is essential to navigate the complexities of the legal system and protect the claimant’s rights.

When Should I Consider Rejecting a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

You should consider rejecting a personal injury settlement offer when it is too low to cover your medical expenses, financial losses, and other damages, when you believe the other party is clearly at fault, or when you have strong evidence to support your claim.

An inadequate settlement offer should be carefully assessed against the total calculated damages to ensure fair compensation. Rejecting such an offer can leverage better negotiations for a resolution reflecting your losses. If you have strong evidence establishing the other party’s fault, it strengthens your case for a higher settlement.

Concrete evidence, such as medical records, witness statements, and accident reports, provides undeniable proof of negligence, which can be compelling during negotiations or litigation. An experienced attorney can effectively use this evidence to present a strong case, cross-reference sources, and strategically negotiate with the opposing party.

What Should I Do Before Rejecting a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

Before rejecting a personal injury settlement offer, it is crucial to consult with an attorney, thoroughly evaluate your case and evidence, and consider the potential time and expense involved in litigation.

Consulting with an experienced attorney provides professional legal advice and helps assess the merits of your case. This ensures that the settlement offer aligns with the strength of your case, potential damages, and legal fees. An attorney can also guide you through the risks and benefits of proceeding to trial, helping you make an informed decision.

Thoroughly evaluating your case involves reviewing all pertinent medical records, accident reports, and witness statements to strengthen your position. Considering the time and expense of litigation is essential, as legal proceedings can be lengthy and financially burdensome, involving court fees and attorney charges that can impact your financial situation.

What Are the Next Steps if I Reject a Personal Injury Settlement Offer?

After rejecting a personal injury settlement offer, the next steps generally involve continuing negotiations, potentially filing a lawsuit, and preparing for trial if necessary.

Continuing negotiations with the insurance company through your attorney can lead to an improved settlement offer, especially when presenting additional evidence like medical records and witness statements. Legal expertise can enhance negotiation strategies, and maintaining open communication with the insurance company is crucial.

If negotiations fail, filing a lawsuit initiates the formal litigation process, requiring comprehensive documentation and awareness of the statute of limitations. Legal representation is highly recommended to navigate complex procedures and represent your interests in court.

Preparing for trial involves gathering and organizing all necessary evidence, preparing witnesses, and developing a legal strategy with your attorney. Effective communication and coordination with your attorney throughout this process ensure your case is presented strongly in court.